Why was my inaccuracy report removed?
Why was my inaccuracy report removed?
One of the strengths of the Pocket Watch Database is the community of enthusiasts that assist in improving the data by compensating for incorrect, fragmented, or missing factory records. Every report must be evaluated with reasonable skepticism before a change to the database can be made with confidence. For this reason, and to prevent confusion amongst future users, some reports may be removed. Here are a few common reasons reports are removed:
- Obvious Improper Lookup. (Example: Stating a serial is grade "P.S. Bartlett" while report on an Elgin movement)
- Obvious Incorrect Information. (Example: Stating a Hamilton serial is grade "975" when comprehensive factory records and observations clearly indicate grade "940")
- Misinformed Report. (Example: Stating an Elgin serial is size 20s or that it only contains 4 jewels)
- Confusing or Ambiguous Information. (Example: Stating an Elgin watch contains a "fast/slow adjuster" or "the serial number is incorrect")
- Repeated Reports (Example: Submitting multiple reports on the same serial number with identical information)
- Using Tone Inconsistent with Site Policy (Example: Using all caps to imply yelling, using improper language, or displaying an antigonistic attitude)
- Suggesting Modifications Based on Unsubstantiated 3rd-Party Sources. (Example: "Production year is 1922 not 1923 according to website X")
- Submitting Personal or Contact Information. (Example: "Please send more information to name@email.com")
- Suggesting Updates to Auto-Generated Information. (Example: "The value should be much more than what is listed")
- Submitting Case Information (Unless Relevant to Factory-Cased Watch). (Example: Reporting "Nickel case with train on the back"). It is better to create a record in your collection and upload images for other users to view.
- Reporting Information only Relevant to Individual Watch. (Example: Stating that a watch is missing a minute hand)
The best practive when submitting an inaccuracy report is to provide as much information as possible about the watch, including anything that is marked on the movement. If you have verified jewel count by removing dial or serviced the watch, please indicate that. Uploading an image of the movement to your collection account is invaluable to verifying certain reported claims. If the watch was seen on a different website or auction page, including the source and/or item number is benecial for evaluation.